Monday, November 30, 2009

Prompt #7

This experience over the last ten weeks has really shown me that teaching has both positive and negative outcomes. It has taught me that every student is different and really do have their own stories, not one is exactly the same. Some have single parents, some are taken care of by other guardians for one reason or another, some have more money than others and some students live in a home where English is never spoken or understood.

One girl named Erin, in particular really taught me about caring and going that one extra step further to help the students. It’s not that they don’t want to learn or understand they just aren’t familiar with how to. I would try and change up how I was teaching certain activities/lessons really helped her, and a number of other students understand better. I can finally see her picking up on things little by little, and putting all the pieces together. She has improved so much in the short amount of time I’ve been going to Joseph L. Smith Elementary School.

This other student named Steven also helped me a lot in forming the beginning of my teacher’s identity. He is five years old like most of the other children in the class but mentally is at a three year old level. They school councilor is having a hard time trying to figure out what is the exact problem behind it all, and has expected Mrs. Blue on a number of occasions to put forth all attention to this one boy. Yes he needs help but so does every other student in the classroom. So Mrs. Blue has showed me a very successful way of trying to keep Steven on track and understanding what is going on while making sure none of the other students are losing out. When I work with Steven one on one he has taught me how to be patient while trying to get him to understand the necessary information, also by thinking outside the box to try and come up with ways to get him to understand. It isn’t his fault he was placed in this class were he obviously is behind, so why should he be left to suffer.

Many of the other students with their different backgrounds have also helped me realize that children need us. Not only to teach them, but to really allow them to grow and learn as much as they can for a successful future, also to feel important because not everyone of them will get it within their homes, unfortunately. They need us to really enjoy what we are doing, to care, to understand, to support and to encourage them. I always had assumptions of what I thought a teacher needed to be like but now I have such a better understanding. Not all teachers feel the same way though, and there are plenty out there that just don’t care. I don’t want to be one of them, and these students really showed me that I can’t be, it’s not fair to them.

I can also say that Mrs. Blue has truly showed me what a “good” teacher is like. She always goes that extra mile sometimes even spending her own money, even though she doesn’t have to, just so her students can receive a better experience while learning. She understands that everyone doesn’t have the same home life and works to do her best to try and supply them with the necessary things to take home with them, such as books and math activities. I’ve talked to another individual helping out within the same elementary school but with the other kindergarten teacher. He said she was nothing like mine, I got extremely lucky. It was a very positive experience that has shown me the teacher I want and need to be to benefit the students for their whole lives, not just while they are with me for a year.

This experience has really changed me for the better and I have come out of it with so much. It reminds me of the Joseph Kahne and Joel Westheimer’s article: In the Service of What? The Politics of Service Learning. I didn’t just end up going to the school to go there as a form of charity and to receive the credit for the hours I needed for the service learing section of this class. I went because I was gaining something from it while I was helping the students who needed it. Each one of the kids I have assisted in the time I have been there has improved so much it’s amazing to me. They have also helped me start forming my teaching identity. Everyone of us benefited from this experience.

4 comments:

  1. Hi Amy,

    I am struck by your first comment, that teaching has both positive and negative outcomes. I would have liked to have read more about what you meant by this.

    I also encourage you to look for the value that diversity brings into your classroom. While it is true that some students have parents who cannot give them academic support, look for ways that the family's traditions can enrich your classroom discussions.

    I am happy that you had a positive role model and applaud your desire to have an impact on their lives beyond the boundaries of the classroom.

    Dr. August

    ReplyDelete
  2. What I meant by teaching having both positive and negative outcomes, has a lot of relation to how the students take in what you are doing for them and the reactions of parents. Some parents show to be against certain things you do to help out their children. Going back to my first post about Mrs. Blue sending home bags of reading and math materials incase the parents aren't able supply them, some parents wrote back not wanting them sent home. Not because they had them but because they didn't want to have to watch the math materials when their younger children were around. So instead of being appreciative like most of the other parents were they just denied it right from the start. They didn't want to take the time or effort to do these activities with their children while keeping their younger ones away. As a teacher hearing something like that just kind of sets you back and makes you think.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Amy,
    I agree that no two students are alike. Students come from different sociocultural, economic, and family structures. It seem as though you had a very positive experience in Mrs. Blue's class. To see a student progress as you described Erin improve must have felt rewarding. In relation to Steven, did he have a hard time learning or behaving? Either way, it is good to experience struggles such as this. In Mrs. Smith's second grade class I constantly experienced learning and behavior problems. Assigned to work with four male students, on fridays, two hours before lunch, I always dealt with issues of behavior. They got very excited many times, and proved a challenge to get them to relax, and continue with the lesson. While children need support and encouragement from their teachers, sometimes it is tough just to get that far with them. This why you get teachers you described as not caring, in many instances, they are burned out, and it is not they do not care. While I very much enjoyed and benefited from my VIPS experience, to be on the receiving end of misbehaving children can be very stressful and draining. Furthermore, it sounds as if Mrs. Blue served as an excellent role model for any person wanting to become a teacher. It is good to have role models such as her. The teacher I worked with, Mrs. Smith, performed a great job with her students. Furthermore, the contributions to my teacher identity derived from the students in her class. Your comparison to Kahne and Westheimer is very suitable for your outlook on education. It is true, if a teacher is going to give one hundred percent, they should be on a mission to change something that is wrong with education. This is a part of my teacher identity, a result of being subjected to teaching methods and traditions that left me alienated and tuned out. It is like you expressed yourself Amy, it is amazing how much you can get out of fifteen hours volunteering in a classroom.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I had one student who really took the initiative to begin everything and tried to help all of the other students. To me he seemed like he didn't need to be working with me. The teacher even said so she had him work with me every once in a while! He also liked to side trakc me and the other students by telling really far fetched stories and ask me what language he was speaking. I knew he was speaking portuguese because he told me one day thats what he spoke at home. He was a great kid and had great intentions of trying to help me help the other students but sometimes it was a little to much!

    I believe that the schools need to work on helping the students who are really behind by pulling them out of class for a little while each day and work with someone. I know that may seem impossible because these schools are under funded and dont have enough teachers in some cases, but I agree with you these kids can not be left to struggle. If they aren't ready to move to the next grade then don't put the student there! It will just hurt them more in the long run.

    I'm glad your teacher was able to show you what a good teacher is! The teacher I had was good, but she was very unorganized and forgot most of the time I was going to be there unless a student told her I was coming. So I ofetn walked into the class with nothing planned from her to work on with the kids. This really had me disappointed, butI tried to work around this and read the books she would give us and sometimes I brought my own things to work on with them! Or I would have them pay attention to what the teacher was presenting to the other students then I would have them grab a copy of the work and I would help them work on their classwork!

    I'm curious on how you liked your placement? Do you think you would teach at an inner city school?

    ReplyDelete